Grilled Ribeye Steak Sandwich Recipe with Caramelized Onions (2024)

Anatomy of a grilled ribeye steak sandwich

Tips & Tricks

Prep ahead:You can make the caramelized onions and mushrooms and the red pepper aioli in advance to make quick work of this sandwich at mealtime. You can even make a big batch of onions and mushrooms and freeze, portioned in ice cube trays! Pop out a couple cubes per sandwich as needed and reheat.

No grill? No problem.You can toast your buns and cook your steak in a cast iron skillet. Toast the buns in batches, set aside, and then cook the steak.

You can melt the cheese onto the sandwiches a couple ways: place the assembled bottom halves on abaking sheetin the oven at 350 for a couple minutes.

Alternately, you can make four piles ofsliced steak, onions, and mushrooms in your heated cast iron skillet. Cover each pile with cheese and place a lid on the pan until the cheese is melted. Then use a spatula to transfer each melty pile onto a saucy ciabatta roll base.

Alternate cuts of steak:You can grill a regular (not thin cut) ribeye to medium rare if you can’t find a thin cut. You can also use:

• Butcher’s steak, also known as hanger steak orskirt steak(that’s what the original sandwich from Caviar and Bananas used)
• Strip steak
• Sirloin steak
• The leftovers from that big ribeye you had last night!

More delicious sandwich recipes

See even more of my favorite sandwich recipes here!

Course: lunch, Main Course

Cuisine: American

Author: Caroline Lindsey

For the caramelized onions and mushrooms

• ▢ 1 tablespoon olive oil
• ▢ 3 tablespoons butter divided
• ▢ 8 oz. sliced mushrooms cremini or baby bella
• ▢ 2 yellow onions medium
• ▢ 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt more to taste
• ▢ 1/2 teaspoon granulated sugar optional

For the roasted red pepper aioli

• ▢ 4 cloves garlic
• ▢ 1 teaspoon kosher salt
• ▢ 1 cup mayonnaise
• ▢ 2 tablespoons lemon juice freshly squeezed
• ▢ 4 tablespoons olive oil
• ▢ 2 whole roasted red peppers
• ▢ dash cayenne pepper to taste

For the sandwich

• ▢ 4 ciabatta rolls
• ▢ 4 thin cut ribeye steaks about 1.25-1.5 lbs total
• ▢ Roasted red pepper aioli make a double batch if using the linked recipe – ingredient quantities listed above are correct
• ▢ ​Caramelized onions and mushrooms
• ▢ ​Baby arugula

For the caramelized onions and mushrooms

• Prepare onions. Cut in half from root to end and peel off papery skin. Quarter and remove the core. Then slice in strips about 1/4″ wide from root to end.

• Preheat a sauté pan orlarge skilletovermedium-high heat. Addolive oiland 1 tablespoon of butter until the butter is melted.

• Add mushrooms in a single layer and sprinkle with alittle salt. Cook for 2 minutes, then flip and cook an additional 2 minutes to get some brown on the edges of the mushrooms.

• Lower the heat to medium low and add remaining butter and onions. Cook uncovered for 30-45 minutes, stirring every 5 minutes or so, until onions are floppy, translucent, and caramel colored. Add a little butter if the mixture starts looking dry.

• Deglaze with about 1/4 to 1/3 cup of water, scraping up any fond that has formed on the bottom of your pan. Add salt to taste and, if desired, a little sugar to bump up the sweetness a bit.

For the roasted red pepper aioli

• While the onions are caramelizing, make the aioli. Finely mince garlic cloves or smash them through a garlic press. Place on acutting board.

• Addkosher saltand smash together with the garlic with the flat of a chef’s knife, scoop it into a pile, and smash it again until it forms a relatively smooth paste.

• Dice the roasted red pepper and place in apaper towelor clean kitchen towel. Squeeze out any excess liquid (otherwise your aioli will be runny). You don’t have to be gentle with it, since you’ll be pureeing it anyway.

• Add garlic paste, mayonnaise, lemon juice,olive oil, roasted red peppers, and cayenne pepper to an immersion blender cup or the bowl of a mini food processor. Blend until smooth.

To cook the steak and rolls

• When the onions have about 15 minutes left to caramelize, preheat your grill over high heat for about 10 minutes.

• Brush both sides of the steak with alittle bitofolive oil(not too much or the grill will flare up), and sprinkle withkosher saltand freshly crackedblack pepper.

• Cut theciabatta rollsin half and butter the insides.

• When the grill is hot, add the rolls butter side down on the grill warming rack (that little grate above the main grill). If you don’t have a warming rack, turn down one burner tomedium heatand place the rolls on that side of the grill. Cook for about 3 minutes until lightly toasted andgolden brown.

• Place steakson the grate over a hot burner. Cook for about 30-45 seconds, flip, and cook for another 30-45 seconds before removing to a plate. Turn the grill down tomedium-low heatbut don’t turn if off yet.

• Let thesteak restfor a couple minutes (it doesn’t need long because it’s so thin) before slicing across the grain with asharp knife. Toss the steak slices in any remaining juices.

To assemble the sandwich

• Spoon two tablespoons of aioli on each side of the roll. On the bottom half of the roll, pile on 1/4 of the steak slices and 1/4 of the caramelized onions and mushrooms. Add two slices of provolone and then put the bottom halves of the sandwiches back on the grill for about 2 minutes, or until the cheese is melted. (You can turn off the grill now)

• Add a handful of arugula on top of themelted cheeseand place the other half of the bun (sauced) on top.

• Cut sandwiches in half, if desired, and enjoy the heck out of it!!